Uber One vs DoorDash DashPass vs Instacart+: Which Delivery Pass Actually Pays Off?
Side-by-side comparison of the three major delivery memberships. We did the math on which one saves the most based on how you actually order.
All three major delivery memberships cost $9.99/month. Same price, different value. Here's how to pick the right one.
The Comparison
| Feature | Uber One | DoorDash DashPass | Instacart+ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | $9.99 ($96/yr) | $9.99 ($96/yr) | $9.99 ($99/yr) |
| Student price | $4.99/mo | $4.99/mo | $4.99/mo |
| Delivery fee | $0 on orders $12+ | $0 on orders $12+ | $0 on orders $35+ |
| Service fee discount | Reduced | Reduced | Reduced |
| Covers restaurants | Yes | Yes | Limited |
| Covers groceries | Yes (Uber Eats) | Some | Yes (primary) |
| Covers rides | Yes (6% credits) | No | No |
| Credit card perks | Amex Platinum ($120/yr) | Chase offers | None major |
| Break-even | ~3 orders/month | ~3 orders/month | ~4 orders/month |
Who Should Get What
Uber One if: You use both Uber Eats AND Uber rides. The ride credits (6%) add value no other pass offers. Best for urban commuters who also order delivery. Students get it for $4.99/mo. Amex Platinum holders effectively get it free.
DoorDash DashPass if: DoorDash is your primary delivery app. DashPass has the widest restaurant selection in most US markets. The $12 minimum is easy to hit on any restaurant order.
Instacart+ if: You order groceries for delivery weekly. The $35 minimum is higher, but grocery orders naturally exceed it. Instacart+ saves the most per order on groceries specifically, since delivery fees on grocery orders are typically $5-8.
None of them if: You order delivery fewer than 3 times per month. At that frequency, the membership costs more than the fees you'd save.
The Hidden Math
The delivery fee is the headline, but the service fee reduction is where the real savings are. All three passes reduce (but don't eliminate) service fees, which can be $3-6 per order. Over 4 monthly orders, that's $12-24 in service fee savings on top of the delivery fee savings.
True monthly savings on 4 orders: ~$20-30 across all three passes. The $9.99 membership pays for itself by the 3rd order.
How Much Would You Save?
How many lines do you need?
$0.00/mo
$0/year
$0.00/mo
$0/year
With 1 line, you'd save
$0/year
That's $0.00/mo back in your pocket
Frequently Asked Questions
Which delivery pass is cheapest?▾
Can I have more than one delivery pass?▾
Which delivery pass covers groceries?▾
Related Savings Guides
How to Lower Your DoorDash DashPass Bill
DoorDash delivery membership. DashPass ($9.99/mo or $96/yr). $0 delivery fee on orders $12+.
$9.99/mo — see savings →How to Lower Your Uber One Bill
Uber delivery + rides membership. $9.99/mo or $96/yr. $0 delivery fee on orders $12+, 6% Uber credits on rides, member-only discounts. Student plan $4.99/mo.
$9.99/mo — see savings →